Two-Ciels-Theory (all hints so far)

crow-ling:

So guys, I decided to make a post with all evidence we have about the Two-Ciels-Theory. My sources are the Kuro-Manga, bb.net/forum and this wonderful post.

our!Ciel is the Ciel we know, real!Ciel is (according to the theory) the twin/look-alike of our!Ciel.

Let’s start with the 

1.Memories of Baron Kelvin

We see Vincent looking to his right side. There is a child on his left side, but we can’t wee what is on his right.

image

A similar situation, we don’t see his right side.

image

There is still a kid, hiding behind Vincent. The kid is on the left side. We don’t see Vincent’s right side again, but when he asks Ciel to introduce himself first, he is touching his head with his right hand, so we can assume he is on Vincent’s right side

image

While real!Ciel introduces himself, our!Ciel keeps on hiding behind Vincent. His health is poor (asthma).

image

According to this great person, the next panel says “Is that you, Ciel??” instead of “Oh Ciel!!!”

image

According to them, it doesn’t say “Ciel asked to come along.” but “This child wanted to come along”

image

Also, they made this great picture.

image

This panel says “those three”, but it’s hard to believe, that the Baron meant Klaus. Also, Klaus is faded out and Vincent is looking and reaching his hand to his left side.

image

2. Memories of the Cage

First, the panel says “Who summoned the demon…?”.

Second, Sebastian is looking for the summoner. As a demon, he should know who summoned him directly (or?)

image

He says that “the price to cross the river has been paid”, while licking over his lips. I think this picture says more than thousand words. Theory:

"You have given a big sacrifice." - words towards real!Ciel

"Now it’s your choice" - words towards our!Ciel

A demon won’t give anyone the choice. Unless the price for Sebastian to cross the river has already been paid. (The price - a soul, what else). So maybe he has devoured real!Ciel’s soul, after being summoned by him, and then he directed his attention to our!Ciel. Sebastian never said he wouldn’t save our!Ciel if he didn’t make a contract with him. He simply gave him the chance to make a contract with him as well (?). our!Ciel's wish is power - the power to take revenge on the ones, who did this to them. What would be real!Ciel's wish then? I guess he asked Sebastian to save our!Ciel, before dying and being devoured by Sebastian.

image

There are many panels, where we see two Ciels, the one in the cage and the other one - being sacrificed. 

image

The next three panels tell us more than one million words

image

a faded out guy, being sacrificed in the background.

image

our!Ciel in the cage, while a look-alike (real!Ciel) is being gragged away. (Pay attention how their hairs are being parted).

image

our!Ciel, remembering the same guy, being sacrificed (again.)

image

image

image

our!Ciel, hesitating to say his name

image

our!Ciel, hesitating to say his name Nr.2 (while looking at the alter, where real!Ciel has been sacrificed)

image

our!Ciel's recent memories

image

image

Since those are our!Ciel's memories, we can assume, that he is the one, holding him himself on the bars. real!Ciel takes his hand and tries to comfort him.

image

Since his mouth is being covered, he can’t scream “Ciel”. The one calling his name is the person, so remained in the cage (our!Ciel)

image

3. Lizzy’s reaction

Lizzy & our!Ciel don’t seem to share the same memories. My theory - Lizzy was (obviously) engaged to real!Ciel. He was the one, who used to spend so much time with her. our!Ciel didn’t so out often, so probably they didn’t know each other that well. 

She seems irritated and our!Ciel is bluffing (obviously, because of his nervousness). 

image

image

image

image

4. Sebastian’s reaction

Normally, people don’t put their own names in quotation marks. Also, saying the ring is the proof, that he is the head of the household, but also saying he doesn’t care about it and throwing it away don’t fit and don’t make much sense.

Sebastian seems shocked as our!Ciel says the name.

image

image

Later, he is laughing at his words.

image

Sebastian, calling our!Ciel a liar, after he refers to himself as Ciel Phantomhive.image

our!Ciel telling Sebastian, that he didn’t go out often (asthma).

image

5.Other hints

"It’s worth more than 2 people”.

image

our!Ciel, talking about Ciel as a third person.

image

our!Ciel, saying he isn’t worth protecting, but rather…?

image

image

————————————-

Summary: I’m sure I have forgotten some hints. However, I hope this has been helpful.

(via azurempress)

1,236 notes

#HOLY SH--

#kuroshitsuji

#ciel phantomhive

#now i want the next chapter!!

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 15 - Quote

“Stories are wild creatures. When you let them loose, who knows what havoc they might wreck?”                                             - Patrick Ness (A Monster Calls)

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 15 - Quote

“Stories are wild creatures. When you let them loose, who knows what havoc they might wreck?”

                                             - Patrick Ness (A Monster Calls)

1 note

#book photo challenge

#books and cupcakes

#patrick ness

#a monster calls

#book quote

#mira's book photo challenge

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 13 - Artistic Cover 

Mirrorscape by Mike Wilks
The image on the cover is already unique, and adding to it is the black gears that you can only clearly see when the book is put under a direct light!

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 13 - Artistic Cover 

Mirrorscape by Mike Wilks

The image on the cover is already unique, and adding to it is the black gears that you can only clearly see when the book is put under a direct light!

2 notes

#book photo challenge

#books and cupcakes

#mirrorscape

#mike wilks

#mira's book photo challenge

blackbean157:

五世代以降もはやく描きたいなあ!

(via rivalhyuu)

3,763 notes

#pokemon

#Pokespe

#cuteeeeee

#my precious babbus

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 11 - Favourite Setting

'Not-so-normal' modern setting, with magic, fantasy and supernatural ♥
Special appearance:
Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman
Alif the Unseen by G. Willow Wilson
Guardian of the Dead by Karen Healey
Lord Loss by Darren Shan
The Lost Hero by Rick Riordan

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 11 - Favourite Setting

'Not-so-normal' modern setting, with magic, fantasy and supernatural ♥

Special appearance:

2 notes

#book photo challenge

#books and cupcakes

#neil gaiman

#G. Willow Wilson

#karen healey

#darren shan

#rick riordan

#mira's book photo challenge

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 5 - Favorite Cover

Stories: All New Tales; Edited by Neil Gaiman & Al Sarrantonio

April Book Photo Challenge: Day 5 - Favorite Cover

Stories: All New Tales; Edited by Neil Gaiman & Al Sarrantonio

#book photo challenge

#books and cupcakes

#neil gaiman

#al sarrantonio

#mira's book photo challenge

Page 1 of 100

1

2

3

4

5

Next ›